Writer Resource

Are You Ready to Join a Critique Group?


Are you thinking about joining a Critique Group for the first time? Or maybe you’re working on a new project and don’t know if it is ready to run the gambit?

Sharing your work with others is a big deal! It is scary, intimating, but also exciting because it may or may not validate all that hard work you’ve put into a piece. You’ll hear directly from readers what did and didn’t work. And though we often prepare ourselves for the worst, sometimes even the most well intentioned feedback can gut us.

So how do you know if you’re ready or not?

Well, first ask yourself this question, what do you want from the critique group?
If you’re looking to join just to hear people praise your writing, think again. Even some of my more polished pieces received harsh or daunting feedback from other writers. Mostly because I thought my piece was ready for the big send-off and they pointed out minor things that sent me back to the editing cave.

If you want to read the work of your fellow writers, want to make new friends, and learn more about the art of critiquing then a critique group is a great place to do all these things.

Bottom line, figure out what you want to gain from the experience, but understand that critique groups are about learning and growing for everyone involved.

Now that you know what you want, the next question should be: Is your WIP is ready?

Sometimes it isn’t a good idea to share the first draft of your current work in progress. Why? Because things change, especially with first drafts. You never know when the chapter you shared with a critique group might change entirely or be completely scrapped.

A critique group is not a group of editors for you to benefit from. Make sure your work has been looked over and revised (at least a little bit) before submitting. Some critique readers can’t help but make line edits in the work they are looking at, but unless your WIP is in its final stages that isn’t the point of the group. Critique groups will discuss your submitted piece in detail, pointing out inconsistencies, style questions, and things that might be confusing to the reader. These are things that should be fixed before in-depth line-editing. If these things haven’t been addressed then it is unfair to expect the group to review your piece when changes can still be made.

Also, if I’m being honest, if you show the first draft you should be prepared to have it ripped apart. It isn’t a fun experience for you or the critique readers, so do everyone a favor and polish it up (just a little bit.)

But this is also where it is important to know your writing group and what you want from the feedback. If you are in the first stages of a WIP and looking for initial reactions to your chapters, feedback on the plot, and to bounce ideas off people this might be a great avenue to do this. Just let the group know what you’re looking for.

On the other side, there are writers who may have looked at their piece a little too much. In this case, maybe the reason you want to find a critique group is that you’ve hit a wall.

What does “hitting the wall” mean? And I have reached this point?

The dreaded wall. It exists. It is tall, cold, possibly guarded by the Night Watch. All writer’s hit this wall when they’ve done the most they can with their project. Maybe the passion is disappearing, maybe you’ve read it so many times everything is blurring together. This is when you can utilize the critique group the best.

Write a list of questions you would like to ask people and bounce ideas off of them. With this, it is important that you set the stage with your readers. I always try to ask people who offer their work what they are looking for in feedback. This is their opportunity to ask tailored questions that they can take back with them. Some examples include, “Did this section make sense? Do I need more tension? Would you keep reading? Why or why not?”

The Relationship is GIVE and TAKE

This is an important part of being in a critique group that I think people overlook sometimes. We get so caught up in the excitement of other people reading our work we forget that it is a GROUP, which means we need to give as well as receive feedback.

This means you’ll be expected to read things that are outside your favorite genre, you’ll probably have to interact with people. But believe me, all these things will make you a better writer and a better member of the writing community.

Final question, Do you want to interact with a physical writing group or stick to virtual communication?

Wait? Do you even have the option? YES!

This is something a lot of people overlook or maybe don’t consider at all. There are pros and cons to both (which will be discussed in another post) but for now, I urge you to consider which one you THINK would best fit your personality and needs. Some people, like me, need to get out of the house and interact with other writers once in a blue moon. For others, having someone critique a piece in front of them is their worst nightmare (I get it.)

If you know you want to meet with a critique group in-person go check out Meetup and Facebook for any local groups that would be that support.

If you are looking for a virtual experience try Wattpad (which accepts most genres) but often gives more encouragement rather then actual feedback.

I’ve found that Science Fiction Writing Workshop also put together this great list of links you can use to find various online critique partners and groups.


I hope these suggestions helped.  Critique groups can be scary but they can also be immensely rewarding. And I firmly believe getting some form of feedback is essential to growing as a writer and accomplishing your goals.

Let me know if you have any online critique group recommendations. I’m always looking.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s